Wednesday, August 31, 2016

Alice in Wonderland - by Lewis Carroll



I must admit that I had expectations going into this book that it would be something worthy of having survived its 150 years.  However, most of the time I was wondering just that, "why do people love this book so much and how has it survived so long?"

Because in my opinion it was this book is reflective of that awkward attempt at humor that you sometimes find amidst the British.  I don't mean that to insult, in fact I sympathize with the person who has difficulty relaxing and making with the funny and maybe even the foolish.  Some British humor is fantastic, perhaps for this very fact that they are serious but have learned to make fun of themselves for it.  Some British, and now I would call Lewis Carroll among them, make a haphazard path towards comedy/absurdity/fantasy/experimentation.  I argue this because Alice begins without much substance, life, or purpose.  I suspect that Carroll meant for this to mirror the aimlessness of childhood.  There is a strong desire for the path to reveal itself to you, but you are waiting for a lot of necessary ingredients first (some education, some space from your parents, maturity, a growing circle of experience, etc.)  And that's where Alice is - she is napping under a tree and the scene is full of ennui, sluggishness, sludge, and malaise.

However, and this is less obvious, I think Carroll only could have used a child as a vehicle for writing this story.  This is because he has no idea how he wants to experiment and grow beyond his own limitations, and as such he is very similar to a child. But he hides behind Alice, letting her ignorance and naivete be obvious whereas his is not.  I was annoyed with this approach even though I understood it.  I think it creates a poor relationship between writer and character and hurts the book.

That said, the book's vignettes became better and better as the story wore on.  I thought the last two chapters had a rhythm that really fit the story (sorry, I can't explain it any better than that, ha, because my writing skills are not so excellent!).  And I wonder if Through the Looking Glass isn't an even better book.

So while I don't necessarily believe this book is a classic based on the merit of its story and writing, there are other reasons that books are considered "classic."  One of these reasons is that what it did it did first and I think that's the answer to why Alice has lasted so long.

Children's literature, believe it or not, has not always been the raging business it is today.  Once upon a time, no one worried about what children would read and to write for children was to dumb down ideas and why not wait for the children to grow up into adult, fully-formed ideas instead?  And there might be something to be said for that argument - but that's another story.

This book was apparently one of the first to write to a child audience.  Also, it's fantastical elements were not common to books either at that point in time.  So as with a book like The Interpretation of Dreams - which was written to be a scientific text but has been dismissed by the scientific community and now is read as a relic of its time - you can argue that Alice's content is not worth it's reputation.  But both books were seminal texts - they went first and for that we remember them. 



Squirrel Seeks Chipmunk by David Sedaris

A curious little book - my thoughts about it are still percolating....

I can say it consists of short stories whose characters are animals.  But they're clearly not animals - they're actually personality types, characters you might know from life that Sedaris is personifying as animals.  

My favorites stories were: "Squirrel Seeks Chipmunk," "The Vigilant Rabbit," "Vomit-Eating Flies," & "The Judicious Hen." 

Most of the stories are almost like fables, there's a moral to take away from them.  The moral, across all stories, tends to be, "don't be that guy."  These are personalities that have gone wrong somewhere and now are wreaking havoc on themselves and those around them. 

A good example is "Vigilant Rabbit."  There are all these creatures in a forest that are having troubles with their neighbors.  They want to build a fence to keep the unwanted out.  Suddenly, a rabbit assumes the role of protector of the area and takes it to heart, a lot to heart.  He is going to guard this forest at all costs.  And he keep some unwanted things out too.  But then, a unicorn tries to enter - and so yeah okay who believes in unicorns???  but that's kinda the point. This rabbit guards the wall, but he can't exercise his own judgment, simply nothing past. 

The unicorn is so fantastical and absurd a creature that one might expect this "challenge" to the rabbit's authority to make him less adamant, less insistent.  Or, you might say, that the unicorn is considered the ultimate symbol of good luck and fortune and that the rabbit might be so impressed that one is actually standing before him.  But rabbit continues to say "no one shall pass me."

So - this is an example of "don't be that guy."  Vigilance - at times a good quality - in rabbit has gone horribly wrong. 

"Vigilant rabbit" is also a good example of the mixture of somber thought and absurd humor that Sedaris weaves in these stories.  Sometimes it is over the top, sometimes it hits closer to the mark.  Throughout though it is a little hokey. But mostly I didn't mind that.  However, I would say that absurd beats out somber in this book for the most part.  Sedaris doesn't always succeed in creating the very difficult to create: dark humor. 

Thursday, July 14, 2016

The Slade House by David Mitchell




I read this book only because it fit the bill for my book club.  I thought other people would like it more than I thought I would like it.  But I am glad that I read it.

David Mitchell is an ambitious contemporary writer.   His most ambitious theme, in my opinion, is to reconcile modern science with a new breed of spirituality.  This spirituality would not be at odds with science but could somehow accommodate it.  

Basic backstory: the Slade House sits on a very small alley that would be easy to walk by without even seeing.  People who visit this place, have been know to disappear.  To say more would give some of the book's surprise away - but I can say that reading this book requires the reader to constantly readjust their expectations.  By this I mean : nothing is certain and take nothing for granted.  

That is what I liked most about this book.  It challenged me to flex my reading skills - something I can't say I've been doing for quite some time.  I like that the book challenged me in this way.  David Mitchell's writing was not fantastic, but it wasn't awful either.  I think that there's not much better you can ask for these days among the contemporary writers.  

David Mitchell probably is a little too ambitious - and this is his downfall as a writer.  He's not quite satisfied selecting a story (or allowing his story to select him) and following it where it leads him.  In my scant experience trying to put pen to paper I think I can say that to do that is very difficult.  More difficult than it sounds like it should be.  David Mitchell inserts a lot of twists or ploys into this story - like supernatural phenomenon - that become the glue that ties the story together.  I don't think a well-written story would be that way.  There were a few times in the book that I actually wondered how he would make the story consistent or, in other words, keep it from becoming ridiculous.  In the books I read, I rarely have occasion to ask myself that and I don't think it's a good sign that a writer has succeeded.  

So I would say that consistency is what was missing from Slade House.  It captured my attention but often I didn't really give it willingly or with much excitement.  There was one piece of the book that was an exception to this though called, "Oink Oink."  This section was about one's willingness to suspend disbelief.  That's always been one of my favorite aspects of story telling.  It's the nexus that makes the journey between reader/writer a collaborative one.  Without it, you're either reading something didactic, or uninteresting, or anyways altogether different than a good story that you're enjoying.  In this section, I liked and cared about the characters - I thought that Mitchell hit his stride - and I enjoyed the book the most.  Sometimes just a little gem makes the time investment of reading something worth it - you remember that one bit.   

If you like supernatural stories, I would recommend giving this book a try. 

Newly found collection of classic books....

I recently began reading "The Invention of Morel" by Adolfo Bioy Casares and have been enjoying it.  The publisher is New York Book Review Classics and I've noticed other books of theirs all around.  Turns out, it's a really cool collection of books.  You can find it here:

http://www.nyrb.com/collections/classics

Wednesday, June 22, 2016

Giovanni's Room by James Baldwin


I first discovered James Baldwin in high school when I read, "Sonny's Blues."  It's a short story about two brothers, one responsible, the other a recovering heroin addict.  The addict seems to have nothing going for him except his ability to play music.  When he plays his music his brother has reason to envy him.  I enjoyed the story, and in particular the writing. 

In college I took a class on the Harlem Renaissance.  We didn't read James Baldwin, but he was interviewed in many of the AV sources we watched during the semester.  And then, he was interviewed by my favorite writer, Robert Penn Warren, for his book Who Speaks for the Negro? about the civil rights movement.  I heard the interview and it was excellent.  You can listen to it here: http://whospeaks.library.vanderbilt.edu/interviews 
Anyway, James Baldwin has been on my radar, on and off, for a long time. 

A friend of mine liked this book so I decided to start with this.  It is my first James Baldwin novel - and I was not disappointed.  A book about homosexuality written in the 1950's already piqued my interest.  It takes place in Paris which has a two-faced way of seeming to accept homosexuals/transvestites and yet persecute them as well. 

The protagonist has had homosexual encounters before the book begins - but at the moment he is dating a woman.  She is away in Spain when the narrator meets Giovanni.  They begin an affair.  Their relationship has few problems on an interpersonal level (there seems to be some difficulty creating roles in a relationship when the pair is of the same gender, and Giovanni is financially unsuccessful - but otherwise the two get along) but the burden of being in a relationship that is not recognized by the world at large is tremendous.  This got me thinking. 

Every relationship is both private (as it should be) and yet also somewhat public.  When/where others recognize you as a couple is the public place of that partnership.  I suppose if you proceed without difficulty that is something you never have to think of.  But here are two people who must think about it.  I find people who must experience life in a different way than most others to be interesting because they reveal something about life you probably didn't know about. 

The problem with Giovanni and David (the narrator) is they react to the public implications of their relationship differently.  That causes them to suffer.  Giovanni is willing to accept public ridicule because he has found something for himself that he values - his relationship with David.  David, however, is extremely at odds with himself.  He doesn't identify as a gay man - he considers homosexuals to be marginalized and he doesn't want to identify himself with a minority.  He struggles with that so much that it's more important than how he feels about Giovanni, who appears to know him better than anyone else in the novel. 

I don't think that Baldwin develops these subjects as well as he might have.  The novel could have done much more with the story it was exploring.  Perhaps, it was too personal for Baldwin to write (he was homosexual and David seems like autobiography).  But occasionally this book has great moments.  I'm glad I read it.

Wednesday, May 25, 2016

Trees seen resting branches while ‘asleep’ for the first time

Trees seen resting branches while ‘asleep’ for the first time: Birch branches droop by as much as 10 centimetres at night, and return to their usual positions at daybreak. It’s not yet clear whether the effect is deliberate or passive